Owners in Kilimani, Westlands, Kileleshwa, Nyali and Diani see the same thing: a furnished apartment can earn twice the monthly rent on Airbnb. The question is how much of that is left after the costs, and how much of your week it takes.
The two models side by side
| Monthly tenant | Short stay | |
|---|---|---|
| Income | Fixed rent, paid monthly | Nightly rate × nights booked |
| Furnishing | Usually unfurnished | Fully furnished, replaced every few years |
| Utilities | Tenant pays power; water often billed | You pay power, water, Wi-Fi, TV |
| Cleaning | Tenant | You, every turnover |
| Fees | Agent fee if you use one | Platform fees on each booking |
| Your time | A few hours a month | Messages, check-ins, turnovers, reviews |
| Risk | Arrears, a long eviction process | Empty nights, damage, double bookings |
| Tax | Monthly Rental Income at 7.5% of gross rent, if eligible | Withholding by the platform, then income tax; see our hosting guide |
A worked example
A one-bedroom apartment in Kilimani. The monthly let would be KES 45,000 unfurnished. As a short stay it lists at KES 5,500 a night.
Extra monthly costs of the short stay:
| Cost | KES a month |
|---|---|
| Furniture and fittings (KES 600,000 over 4 years) | 12,500 |
| Power, water, Wi-Fi, TV | 9,500 |
| Restock (toiletries, coffee, gas) | 3,000 |
| Repairs reserve | 3,000 |
| Fixed extra costs | 28,000 |
Per-night costs:
| Cost | KES a night |
|---|---|
| Platform fee (about 15% of 5,500) | 825 |
| Cleaning and laundry (KES 2,000 a turnover, 3-night average stay) | 667 |
| Kept per night | 4,008 |
Break-even occupancy: (45,000 + 28,000) ÷ 4,008 = 18.2 nights a month, about 61%.
Below 18 nights, the monthly tenant earns more for far less work. At 22 nights (73%), the short stay earns about KES 15,000 a month more than the tenant before tax. That is the reward for running a small hotel.
What moves the answer
- Location. Short stays work near offices, embassies, hospitals, the airport and the coast. In a dormitory town with few visitors, occupancy rarely holds.
- Season. December, August and conference weeks fill up; February and May can be thin. Use a year of numbers, not your best month.
- Your time. If you pay a manager 15 to 20% of revenue, add it to the per-night costs and the break-even rises.
- Direct guests. Returning guests and corporate clients who book directly save the platform fee. Each one lowers your break-even.
- Rules. Your building's rules, your lease and the permits in our hosting guide can rule short stays out before the numbers do.
A middle path
Many owners mix the two:
- one unit in a block as a short stay, the rest let monthly;
- short stays in the high season, a three- to six-month furnished let in between;
- a furnished monthly let to expatriates or contract workers, which earns more than unfurnished without nightly turnovers.
Track it to know it
The comparison only works with real numbers: nights booked, what guests paid, what each channel kept and what you spent. Cribz records each booking with its channel fee and works out occupancy, average nightly rate, net income and profit after expenses each month, next to your monthly tenants in the same workspace. See Cribz for hosts, or work out your tenants' side with the rental income tax calculator.